
It's all verifiable: archives, resources and stuff they might not tell you.
A comprehensive archive chronicling the activities of Motor City casino syndicators (Marian Ilitch & Family, Michael Malik, Herb Strather, etc.); their associates, partners & affiliates; and the unfulfilled commercial & Indian casino schemes they are bankrolling in Michigan (Port Huron, Flint Township), Hawaii (Waikiki), New York (Long Island / The Hamptons), and California (Barstow).
Thursday, January 03, 2008
BarWest drops California Lobbyist Keith Olberg

Wednesday, August 01, 2007
It appears the Big Lagoon Rancheria failed to file lobbying disclosures for 2nd Quarter 2007
However, two Sacramento-based lobbying firms have filed disclosure reports indicating they represented and were retained by the Big Lagoon Rancheria during the 2nd Quarter 2007:
The two firms indicate they were paid $55,465.27 collectively to represent the Big Lagoon Rancheria during the 2nd Quarter 2007.
By annotation buried in the lobbying firm's disclosure documents, payments to Governmental Advocates, Inc. for representation of Big Lagoon Rancheria interests were made by Detroit-based Barwest LLC (which the report mis-identifies as "Bar West,Inc."). No such notation is included in the Capitol Ventures disclosure; however, Capitol Ventures indicates it's client is "Big Lagoon Rancheria/Barwest." Former California Assemblyman R. Keith Olberg is Capitol Ventures, Roseville's only registerd lobbyist.
A third Sacrmento firm, C.W. ‘Nick’ Medeiros, Incorporated reported it represented the Big Lagoon Rancheria but did not receive any payments from the tribe during the 2nd Quarter 2007.
Barwest LLC has contracts to develop and manage any future casino resorts in Barstow, CA for the Big Lagoon Rancheria and Los Coyotes Band of Cahuilla and Cupeno Indians. Michael J. Malik, Sr. and Mrs. Marian Ilitch are principals behind Detroit-based Barwest LLC. Ilitch owns 100% of Detroit's MotorCity Casino which she purchased from Mandalay Resort Group/MGM Mirage. Her acquisition of MotorCity Casino helped facilitate the 2005 merger of Mandaly Resort Group and MGM Mirage. Ilitch and her husband Mike Ilitch co-founded Little Caesar Pizza and the family's empire includes the Detroit Tigers and Detroit Red Wings among other sports, entertainment and dining enterprises. Mike Ilitch is listed among Forbes 400 Richest Americans.
You may want to review these additional posts:
- Where there's smoke, there's fire: Attorney attempts to clean up FPPC mess created when he failed to report $63,805 arrangement with lobbyist
- Irregularities in Lobbying Disclosures for Barstow Casinos bankrolled by Ilitch Detroit-based Syndicate
- Lobbyist failed to report $66,677 from Big Lagoon Rancheria
- By Bankrolling lobbying expenses behind the scenes, Casino Syndicators were free to flow political cash
- Detroit-based Barwest LLC has paid more than $613,439 for casino lobbying support in Sacramento the last 18 months
- Amended lobbying registration suggests contracts with California tribes are being managed in Detroit, Michigan
- More Lobbying Irregularities related to Barstow Casino raising question about who's paying the bills and why they are hiding
- Lobbyist indicates Senator Wiggins would sponsor Ilitch Family's Barstow casinos legislation
- Casino Developer & Author of SB 157 to approve dual Barstow casinos apparently violated political reform laws
- SF Chronicle editors warned Willie Brown commands a high price and leaves little paper trail
- What was Willie Brown's role with Barwest's original Barstow casino proposal?
- Ilitch Casino Lobbyist Keith Olberg is also president of a GOP attack committee funded by "swift-boat" founders
- Wife of Lobbyist returns to position in Governor's Office
- FPPC Enforcement Decisions: Casino syndicator's Major Donor violations revealed
- Yet again Michael Malik shows contempt for CA's Political Reform Laws with reporting inconsistencies
Wednesday, July 18, 2007
Prediction for Detroit Tigers is classic George W. Bush

In an interview with ESPN, President George W. Bush complimented Tigers owner Mike Ilitch and predicted the Tigers will return to the World Series.
"I think Detroit will be in the World Series," Bush said. "I think they'll nose out Boston. I know that may be counterintuitive, but their young pitching is great, and they've got the flamethrower Zumala back."
He was later informed the flamethrower's name is Zumaya.
note: Bush once predicted R. Keith Olberg would be California's next Secretary of State -- voters had a different idea. So instead, Olberg was hired as the lobbyist for Marian Ilitch's California gambling interests. And then remember Bush also predicted that Sadam Hussein had Weapoons of Mass Destruction too (WMDs).
Friday, June 01, 2007
Wife of Lobbyist returns to position in Governor's Office
Delette (Knonenberg) Olberg, 40, of Roseville, has been appointed chief deputy appointments secretary in the Office of the Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger; an appointment that does not require Senate confirmation. (Press Release)
She most recently served as chief-of-staff for Assemblyman Sam Blakeslee, a position she had previously held before being appointed director of scheduling for the Office of Governor Schwarzenegger in January 2006.
Her experience also includes five years as membership coordinator for the Chemical Industry Council of California. She at one time was director of law and government affairs for AT&T.
Delette Olberg is the wife of former conservative GOP Assemblyman R. Keith Olberg.
Mr. Olberg is a lobbyist for the Detroit gaming syndication Barwest LLC and involved with several controversial political action committees including the 527-group Economic Freedom Fund, a conservative 527 committee of which Olberg is president. Employing Olberg via Barwest LLC are Mrs. Marian Ilitch and Michael J. Malik, Sr.
Mr. Olberg reports Barwest LLC and its affiliates paid him $250,000 in 2006.
| Delette Knonenberg Olberg | |
| Since Mar 23, 2007 | Chief Deputy Appointments Secretary, Office of Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger; annual compensation of $118,00 |
| 2006 – 2007 | Chief of Staff, Assemblyman Sam Blakeslee; GOP caucus payroll, $99,000 per year |
| Jan 2006 | Director of Scheduling, Office of Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger; annual compensation of $110,004 |
| 2004 -- 2005 | Chief of Staff, Assemblyman Sam Blakeslee |
| 2002 – 2003 | Director of member services and GOP consultants, Assembly Republican Caucus |
| 2001 -- 2002 | Director of energy and technology, California Manufacturers and Technology Association |
| 2000 – 2001 | Chief of Staff, Assemblywoman Lynn Daucher |
| 1995 – 2000 | Chief of Staff, Assemblyman Keith Olberg (Delette Knonenberg) |
| Unknown 5 year period | Membership Coordinator, Chemical Industry Council of California |
| unknown | Director of law and government affairs, AT&T |
Sunday, February 25, 2007
Where there's smoke, there's fire: Attorney attempts to clean up FPPC mess created when he failed to report $63,805 arrangement with lobbyist
Several weeks ago, The Verifiable Truth (TVT) began breaking reports exposing lobbying disclosures discrepancies and violations involving the Los Coyotes and Big Lagoon Indian Tribes, several lobbying firms and “silent” parties bankrolling and directing the lobbying effort.
Immediately, Michael Yaki, a Bay area attorney retained by Detroit casino syndicators to represent the Los Coyotes Indian Tribe attempted to “clean up” a year’s worth of fraudulent lobbying disclosures he filed, under penalty of perjury, as the Tribe’s representative. Amended filings indicate Yaki failed to report almost 30% of what was really spent by (or under cover of) the Los Coyotes Tribe on lobbying -- failed to report close to $65,000 paid to lobbyist R. Keith Olberg (a former Assemblyman and candidate for statewide constitutional office).
Yaki simply took lobbying reports filed by Governmental Advocates, Inc. and Capitol Ventures, Roseville and amended a years worth of his filings for Los Coyotes with data to match what was reported by the two lobbying firms and swiftly submitted them as amended disclosures. That just further complicated the mess.
Now, when the total lobbying fees reported by so-called partners the Big Lagoon and Los Coyotes Indians are added up and compared with the total fee income reportedly received by the two lobbying firms, things still don’t add up!
2005/2006 Legislative Session Lobbying Payments | Total |
Two Barwest Tribes report Paying Lobbyists | $534,144 |
Two Lobbying Firms report Receiving Payments of | $463,928 |
unreported by lobbyists | $70,216 |
The tribes say they’ve paid two lobbying firms collectively $70,216 more than the lobbying firms have reported receiving in payment disclosures.
The truth is, despite Yaki’s “clean up” attempt, his Indian clients most likely didn’t pay anything to either lobbying firm; some “intermediaries” have been paying the bills and hiding behind the tribe. Neither attorney Yaki nor any other representative of Los Coyotes ever authorized Capitol Ventures, Roseville to represent the Los Coyotes Indians. So who did?
Either the tribe’s attorney Mr. Yaki was negligent and failed to report it had engaged and was paying Capitol Ventures, Roseville for nearly a year; OR the lobbying firm has been employed by others whose interests' are certainly being represented and yet neither the lobbying firm nor the lobbying firm’s employer have reported their relationship.
California’s political reform laws are meant to bring politics out of smoke filled rooms and expose who’s behind various political activities; who the real parties are attempting to influence public policy; where the true source of money trails from. These parties discussed here are playing games trying to avoid disclosure.
The parties involved here know better: they’re seasoned political operatives, former political candidates, lobbyists, experienced FPPC filers, White House appointees and lawyers. Mr. Yaki has been involved in previous FPPC findings involving his donors' improper disclosures/failures to disclose. J. Richard Eichman, CPA, who files reports on behalf of the Big Lagoon Rancheria has been filing FPPC disclosures for more than 12 years. This incidence and the numerous other reporting violations that continue to arise are cause enough for some more thorough and comprehensive investigation of lobbying and political activity by the FPPC and Attorney General. A group of professionals with this much experience hardly make unintended "mistakes" with this level of frequency.
“Where there’s smoke, there’s fire!”
Thursday, February 08, 2007
Irregularities in Lobbying Disclosures for Barstow Casinos bankrolled by Ilitch Detroit-based Syndicate
Records available from the California Secretary of State at (cal-access) document that The Big Lagoon Rancheria tribe has reported paying $99,000 to Sacramento GOP politico turned lobbyist Keith Olberg (Capitol Ventures, Roseville) through September 2006.
Lobbying disclosure documents filed by Olberg with the California Secretary of State, under penalty of perjury, only report he received $62,036 from The Big Lagoon Rancheria.
Olberg also reported receiving $62,036 from Los Coyotes Band of Cahuilla & Cupeno Indians, but in disclosure reports filed for the Los Coyotes tribe there is never a reference to Olberg or payments to Olberg’s firm. Further, there are no official documents to indicate Los Coyotes tribe has ever authorized Olberg’s activity.
The Los Coyotes tribe has reported it is represented by Governmental Advocates, and that firm was paid $102,012 to represent the Los Coyotes tribe. Although not disclosed by Los Coyotes, documents filed by Governmental Advocates suggest in a footnote that the Los Coyotes bills are being paid by a benefactor:
Governmental Advocates also represents the Big Lagoon Rancheria. There are no apparent discrepancies between reports filed by the Big Lagoon Rancheria and Governmental Advocates but those reports do indicate the same benefactor footing the Los Coyotes tribe’s bills is paying the bills for the Big Lagoon tribe. The Big Lagoon tribe has never disclosed a third party may be paying its bills.
A third California lobbying firm headed by Nick Medeiros is acknowledged as representing the interests of the Big Lagoon Rancheria since August 2005 but reports filed by Medeiros and the tribe do not indicate he has ever been paid for its services.
The apparent attempts to conceal payments for lobbying and political activity seem contrary to the intent of California’s political reforms. This activity suggests there is something worth hiding.
Driving the tribes’ quest to relocate casinos to Barstow is a Michigan casino syndicate headed by gambling maven Marian Ilitch owner of Detroit’s MotorCity Casino. She and her husband Mike Ilitch are co-founders of Little Caesar’s Pizza and owners of the Detroit Tigers and Detroit Red Wings. Ilitch controls at least 110 acres in Barstow and after approaching the City about a possible casino in 2001-2002, Ilitch and her partner Michael J. Malik, Sr. were introduced to leaders of the Los Coyotes tribe. After failing to get a stand alone casino approved by Governor Schwarzenegger in 2004, the Ilitch syndicate was introduced to the family that makes up the Big Lagoon Rancheria.
In September 2005, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger signed agreements with both tribes that could allow them to open casinos in Barstow, Calif., since then the tribe’s and their lobbyist have failed to develop support for their plans in the state legislature. Last summer a state Assembly committee rejected the agreements. The agreements must be ratified by both California’s Assembly and Senate in order for them to be valid. Absent concurrence in the state legislature, the agreements are set to expire in 2007.
Ilitch tapped Olberg to head her casino syndicate’s lobbying effort in Sacramento during 2006. Ilitch’s team racked up more than $400,000 in fees to Sacramento Lobbyists in 2006 trying to build support among lawmakers. Since 2002, Ilitch, her partners and affiliates have paid Capitol Hill Lobbyists almost $3 million for similar support.
Olberg is a former GOP Assemblyman and candidate for Secretary of State and Congress. He is also president of the 527-political organization, Economic Freedom Fund; a group TPM Muckraker referred to as a “GOP Attack Group.” Olberg’s wife, Delette Olberg, was employed as Governor Schwarzenegger’s director of scheduling during 2006.
You may want to review these additional posts:
- Where there's smoke, there's fire: Attorney attempts to clean up FPPC mess created when he failed to report $63,805 arrangement with lobbyist
- It appears the Big Lagoon Rancheria failed to file lobbying disclosures for 2nd Quarter 2007
- Lobbyist failed to report $66,677 from Big Lagoon Rancheria
- By Bankrolling lobbying expenses behind the scenes, Casino Syndicators were free to flow political cash
- Detroit-based Barwest LLC has paid more than $613,439 for casino lobbying support in Sacramento the last 18 months
- Amended lobbying registration suggests contracts with California tribes are being managed in Detroit, Michigan
- More Lobbying Irregularities related to Barstow Casino raising question about who's paying the bills and why they are hiding
- Ilitch Casino Lobbyist Keith Olberg is also president of a GOP attack committee funded by "swift-boat" founders
- Lobbyist indicates Senator Wiggins would sponsor Ilitch Family's Barstow casinos legislation
- SF Chronicle editors warned Willie Brown commands a high price and leaves little paper trail
- What was Willie Brown's role with Barwest's original Barstow casino proposal?
- Wife of Lobbyist returns to position in Governor's Office
Tuesday, February 06, 2007
More Lobbying Irregularities related to Barstow Casino raising question about who's paying the bills and why they are hiding
Why isn't the Detroit Casino Syndicate called Barwest LLC registered as a lobbyist employer?
Where is the money coming from that Barstwest uses to pay lobbyists?
Who is hiding behind Big Lagoon and Los Coyote Indian Tribes?
Former GOP Assemblyman and candidate for Secretary of State Keith Olberg (Capitol Ventures, Roseville) filed disclosure documents with the Secretary of State for each of the first three quarters of 2006 under penalty of perjury and reported he'd been paid $63,805 by the Los Coyotes Tribe in connection with a scheme to relocate two Indian casinos to Barstow.
The Los Coyotes Tribe also filed lobbyist employer disclosure documents during the first three quarters of 2006 and reported a relationship with another firm, Governmental Advocates, but not with Olberg.
Lobbying Payment Disclosures 2006
31-Mar | 30-Jun | 30-Sep | 31-Dec | Total | |
Los Coyotes reported | $0 | $0 | $0 | $31,482 | $31,482 |
Olberg reported | $15,000 | $24,769 | $24,036 | $31,482 | $95,287 |
∆ -$63,805 |
As reported in disclosures on file with the CA Secretary of State
In its final disclosure report for the year, in addition to reporting collective payments totaling $138,446 to Governmental Advocates, the Los Coyotes Tribe reported a payment of $31,482 to Olberg for representation during the last quarter of the legislative cycle. Olberg's final report indicated the Los Coyotes Tribe had paid him each of four quarters for a total of $95,287 during 2006 (3x times what the tribe reported paying him).
Why did the Los Coyotes fail to report more than $63,000 paid to lobbyist Olberg during 2006?
So who is really paying Olberg? And whose interests does he really represent? He's made public references to a team of people in New York, Washington, Michigan and Las Vegas who are working to bring the Casinos and Resorts to Barstow. There are no notations on Olberg's reports to suggest someone else paid him nor any disclosures or activity authorizations by another lobbyist employer to coincide with payments Olberg claims to have received from Los Coyotes Tribe. However, buried as a footnote in the final report filed by the Los Coyotes Tribe was the following: ""Payments made on behalf of Los Coyotes by Barwest LLC, 2211 Woodward Avenue, Detroit, Michigan, 48201." That lead to a similar discovery buried in the 20-page Governmental Advocates disclosure: "**FEES RECEIVED THROUGH INTERMEDIARY BAR WEST,INC." The Detroit Casino Syndicate (Barwest) appears to be the conduit for bankrolling and directing lobbying efforts and avoiding any proper disclosures hiding behind the Los Coyotes Tribe. They failed to report the syndicate as a lobbyist employer and they can hide the source of the funds they used to pay the lobbyists. AND they are free to give political cash ($85,000 last year) to politicians their partners are lobbying for votes. Those bankrolling the plan for twin casinos in Barstow are breaking the spirit of California's political reforms act and maybe even breaking California law.
You may also want to review these posts:
The Verifiable Truth: Irregularities in Lobbying Disclosures for Barstow Casinos bankrolled by Ilitch Detroit-based Syndicate
The Verifiable Truth: Lobbyist failed to report $66,677 from Big Lagoon Rancheria
The Verifiable Truth: By Bankrolling lobbying expenses behind the scenes, Casino Syndicators were free to flow political cash
Saturday, February 03, 2007
Ilitch Casino Lobbyist Keith Olberg is also president of a GOP attack committee funded by "swift-boat" founders
R. Keith Olberg, a former California Assemblyman, is EFF's president, according to the disclosure report filed October 1, 2006, by EFF with the Federal Election Commission. In October 2002, LA Weekly described Olberg, who was then running for California Secretary of State, as a "veteran Republican wonk and legislator." Olberg's wife, Delette Olberg, is "a $99,000-a-year official on the [California] Assembly GOP caucus staff." [2]
The group works with Meridian Pacific, Inc., "a two-year-old California consulting firm", Rood wrote September 14, 2006. As "further testament to its GOP bonafides," Meridian is "headed by" John Peschong, a "onetime senior Republican National Committee official [who] joined Meridian Pacific in 2005, after seven years as the Western States Director for the RNC," Rood wrote.
On September 14, 2006, EFF's "sole backer" was Texas millionaire Robert J. Perry, "who founded the infamous Swift Boat Veterans for Truth group during the 2004 elections," Rood wrote. [3]
Perry was joined September 21, 2006, by Carl H. Lindner, "part owner of the Cincinnati Reds and No. 133 on the Forbes 400 list of richest Americans, [who] has ponied up $50,000 to EFF. More precisely, EFF has recorded a $50,000 donation from the same address as Lindner uses in other FEC reports," Josh Marshall wrote October 4, 2006.
Marian Ilitch has employed Olberg since January 2006 and paid him nearly $200,000 to convince Sacramento lawmakers to approve her unorthodox plan to relocate two tribes clear across the state so she can open two Indian Casinos in Barstow, Calif. Marian's husband Mike Ilitch is owners of the Detroit Tigers and Detroit Red Wings and No. 242 on the Forbes 400 list of richest Americans. They have ponied up thousands to former congressman Richard Pombo which landed them at #9 on Pombo's list of Top Ten Donors -- beating out Jack Abramoff who was #10.
EFF hired Stevens Reed Curcio & Potholm, an Arlington, Virginia, "media firm, to prepare ads against" Democratic incumbents Reps. Alan Mollohan (D-WV) and Jim Marshall (D-GA), Paul J. Nyden reported September 14, 2006, for McClatchy-Tribune Business News.
SRC&P "also prepared the Swift Boat ads attacking [John] Kerry's military service in Vietnam, where he won a Silver Star, a Bronze Star and three Purple Hearts," Nyden wrote.
By the time the Economic Freedom Fund was only a month old, it had already been very active, dropping half a million bucks on negative TV ads against" Mollohan and Marshall, Paul Kiel of TPM Muckraker wrote September 14, 2006.
Friday, February 02, 2007
Lobbyist failed to report $66,677 from Big Lagoon Rancheria
California lobbying disclosure reports have been filed through December 31, 2006 closing out the 2005-2006 legislative cycle. After our last post on this matter, " Irregularities in Lobbying Disclosures for Barstow Casinos bankrolled by Ilitch Detroit-based Syndicate ," operatives for Marian Ilitch attempted some creative accounting and filed an amended document on behalf of the Big Lagoon Rancheria when complying with the January 31, 2007 filing deadline. There's no covering up the discrepancies that are well documented after 4 filing periods.
Big Lagoon Rancheria represents making payments of $161,964 to R. Keith Olberg for lobbying activity during quarters 5-8 of the 2005-06 Legislative cycle. Although there is nothing on file authorizing Olberg to undertake lobbying activity on behalf of the Big Lagoon tribe, the tribe reported payments to Olberg for lobbying services each of the final four quarters:
Lobbying Payment Disclosures 2006
31-Mar | 30-Jun | 30-Sep | 31-Dec | Total | |
Big Lagoon reported | $30,000 | $46,000 | $23,000 | $62,964 | $161,964 |
Olberg reported | $15,000 | $24,769 | $24,036 | $31,482 | $95,287 |
∆ $66,677 |
As reported in disclosures on file with the CA Secretary of State
Based on disclosure reports, Olberg failed to acknowledge $66,677 in payments Big Lagoon indicates it made to Olberg in quarters 5-8 of the 2005-06 cycle.
In quarters 5 & 6, Olberg reports his "employer" as "BIG LAGOON RANCHERIA" and then a subtle change is made in quarters 7 & 8 when Olberg lists his employers as "Big Lagoon Rancheria/Barwest." There are no records of disclosure on file for Barwest as a lobbyist employer
You may also want to review these posts:
The Verifiable Truth: Irregularities in Lobbying Disclosures for Barstow Casinos bankrolled by Ilitch Detroit-based Syndicate
The Verifiable Truth: More Lobbying Irregularities related to Barstow Casino raising question about who's paying the bills and why they are hiding
The Verifiable Truth: By Bankrolling lobbying expenses behind the scenes, Casino Syndicators were free to flow political cash
Tuesday, January 30, 2007
Lobbyist indicates Senator Wiggins would sponsor Ilitch Family's Barstow casinos legislation

Wiggins was elected to the California Senate in November 2006 to fill the coastal Humboldt County seat vacated due to term limits by Wesley Chesbro (D-Arcata).
Chesbro attempted to shepherd the same plans through the legislature in 2006 but a Senate Committee chaired by Dean Florez (D-Bakersfield) failed to take any action on the plans in March 2006 and an Assembly committee chaired by Jerome Horton (D-Inglewood) voted to reject the agreements in June. The agreements with the Los Coyotes and Big Lagoon Rancheria Bands of Indians, which must be ratified by the legislature this year or they expire, were originally signed by Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger in 2005.
Ilitch's Team has known since last summer that it would need to find a new author for legislation in a 2007 session with Chesbro's departure. Unless there is a significant show of support from an additional block of legislators at this anticipated announcement and if the author they've secured is Wiggins, it would further signal the agreements are on the same doomed path they took in 2006. If Wiggins refused to carry the legislation on Ilitch's behalf that would also be troubling news.
TVT has welcomed more than 178,000 unique vistors
Since our first post, more than 178,000 visitors have accessed the details compiled uniquely at TVT.
The citizen activists behind TVT wish to extened a big "THANK YOU" to all those who have provided "tips" -- contributed pictures, documents, link suggestions, leads, reports, insight and comments. Your trust and confidence in TVT has allowed us to create a comprehensive resource that thousands of others -- including bloggers, journalists, Members of Congress and other local citizen activists around the country -- have come to rely upon.
We invite feedback and constructive comment and want you to know you are welcome to do that here in "comments" or by contacting us directly and confidentially via allverifiable@gmail.com
Google News: Indian Gaming
NEWS: Bay Mills Indian Community & Casino Proposals
NEWS: Shinnecock Indian Nation (Gateway Casino Resorts) Casino Proposals
NY Times: Shinnecock Indian Nation
NEWS: Los Coyotes Indian Tribe
NEWS: Los Coyotes / Barwest Barstow Casino Proposals
NEWS: Michael J. Malik, Sr.
NEWS: Marian Ilitch
Muckety.com: Mapping Social Networks