Monday, June 18, 2007

Ilitch guaranteed most lucrative deal in NHL if he stays at Joe Louis Arena


6.18.07


Wings winners in Joe Louis deal
Coleman Young's '70s agreement to keep team in Detroit is the most lucrative in the NHL.


David Josar / The Detroit News

DETROIT -- In the mid-1970s, then-Red Wings owner Bruce Norris threatened to move the team to Pontiac. To get them to stay, then-mayor Coleman A. Young put together an incentive-laden contact that would guarantee the team remain in the Motor City until 2008.

The agreement is considered the most lucrative in the NHL and is a prime reason the team has increased in value from the $8 million Mike Ilitch paid for it in 1982 to an estimated $288 million today, according to Forbes magazine.

The lease not only covers Joe Louis, but also the 12,191-seat Cobo Arena and a 500-space parking lot. Next year, it will automatically renew for 20 years at generally the same generous terms -- and for another 10 years after that unless Olympia Arenas, a company controlled by Mike and Marian Ilitch, decides to nix the arrangement.

Highlights of the deal:


  • The city has no say in whether the contract will be extended. The decision is made unilaterally by the Red Wings, which can keep terms that will only grow more financially favorable for the team.

  • The city of Detroit will provide free police protection for the games at Joe Louis and Cobo Arena. In addition, the city provides landscaping and snow removal. Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick has said he would try to get the Lions, Red Wings and the Ilitch-owned Tigers, to pay something toward offsetting the cost of providing officers but has been unsuccessful. Meanwhile, the city is charging nonprofit community festivals, such as the Detroit Festival of the Arts and Comerica Tastefest, for police services.

  • The Ilitches pay $25,000 a month to rent Joe Louis -- built in 1979 for $30 million -- and $12,500 a month for Cobo Arena.

  • The city collects a 10 percent surcharge on tickets at Joe Louis and 7.5 percent for Cobo Arena. It also gets a 10 percent cut of all concession sales and about 7 percent of the luxury suite fees. For the past five years, those fees and rent have given the city about $5 million a year in revenue.

  • The city provides up to $500,000 a year for capital improvements to Joe Louis.

  • Olympia gets 50 parking spaces for its own use in the Joe Louis lot.

  • A hefty property tax break is included in the agreement. Like many lease agreements, the Ilitches are responsible for the property taxes. However, a clause caps the Ilitches' property tax liability at $252,000. By comparison, the owner of a $30 million building in Detroit -- the construction cost of Joe Louis nearly 30 years ago -- pays roughly $1 million a year.

  • If the Red Wings decide to extend the lease, the city would no longer be able to tack on up to a 10 percent surcharge on tickets to games and events that accounted for $2.7 million in revenue in the 2006-07 fiscal year. And in five years, Detroit would no longer get a cut of concessions and suite rentals. Olympia Entertainment would lose its property tax break, however, and would be liable for about $1 million annually.

You can reach David Josar at (313) 222-2073 or djosar@detnews.com

http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070618/SPORTS0103/706180377

Behind the Scenes: Ilitch and City in Hockey Arena showdown

note: on September 29, 2006 the Detroit News ran a story entitled "Ilitch to announce Joe's fate within 30 days." An announcement is 232 days over due (or almost 8 months).

6.18.07

The lease agreement between Detroit and the Ilitches for Joe Louis Arena, above, and Cobo Arena expires in August 2008.


Ilitch has to decide the Joe's fate soon
Wings must renew lease in Aug. or go for new arena



David Josar / The Detroit News

DETROIT -- Mike Ilitch and the Detroit Red Wings have two months to tell city leaders whether they will exercise their option to renew for 20 years the exclusive lease -- considered the best of any NHL team -- for Joe Louis Arena and Cobo Arena.

The Aug. 16 deadline is expected to set in motion intense deal-making and negotiations that will involve the future of Cobo Arena, Joe Louis Arena -- the home of the Red Wings -- and how much money the state, city and taxpayers are willing to toss in to subsidize a new Detroit hockey arena.

"They talk to us all the time," Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick said. "They're still trying to decide whether to stay and improve the (Joe Louis) facility or move."

Ilitch, whose fortune started with a suburban pizza place in 1959, bought the Red Wings for $8 million in 1982. The team is now worth an estimated $258 million -- a value due in large part to the bargain-basement lease on the Joe. According to Forbes magazine, he is among America's richest citizens, worth $1.5 billion...

Some executives for Ilitch's companies are not sure city officials have the right deadline date. They note, for example, the team did not take occupancy for more than a year after the agreement was signed, a situation they suggest pushes the renewal date back...

Either way, a showdown is expected this summer...

Council doesn't like deal
So far, the Red Wings and their owners have remained quiet. The city isn't saying much, either.

The city recently sold to Olympia Development, another of the Ilitch-run companies, two vacant, tax-reverted parcels behind the Fox for $200,000. Earlier this year, the city awarded Olympia development rights for the historic GAR building nearby.

The Ilitches are known as hard negotiators. In the 1990s, Mike Ilitch threatened to move the Tigers unless the team got a new ballpark -- which it did, across Woodward Avenue from his Fox Theatre and Hockeytown Cafe.

This time, Ilitch is in the driver's seat, thanks to the deal brokered in 1979 by Mayor Coleman Young that kept the team from moving to Pontiac.

Ilitch will decide whether to extend the lease -- the city has no vote -- and if the pact is extended, it will become even more favorable for him and the Red Wings.

Currently, the city imposes up to a 10 percent surcharge on tickets sold to events at Joe Louis and Cobo Arena; Detroit gets a cut of concessions and luxury suites.

If the lease is extended, the city will lose the surcharge -- which brings in about $2.5 million a year -- and, in five years, its share of concession and suite revenue. Council fiscal analyst Irv Corley, in a February report to the council on the lease, said the contract is "strongly in favor" of the Ilitch companies. He called it "convoluted" and questioned whether the city was receiving its fair share of concession sales.

The lease is much more lucrative than those of other teams. For example, the San Jose Sharks pay $1.6 million a year for the building and get a small percentage of ticket sales, but the team also chips in money for capital improvements and agreed to split with San Jose any profits from naming rights.

Council members have been upset for several years about the lease arrangement, but their anger reached a new level in February, when the fiscal analyst, at their urging, probed the specifics of the arrangement between Detroit and the Ilitch-family controlled company.

"This is clearly a sweetheart deal, and if they (the city law department) don't find a way to terminate this contract I'm going to turn it over to the FBI because this is ridiculous," Councilwoman Barbara-Rose Collins said. (Complete Story)

Sunday, June 17, 2007

Family Affair: Members of Congress pay family members with political funds

6.17.07

Lawmakers used campaign funds to pay relatives

By Matt Kelley, USA TODAY

...Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) found nearly $3.5 million in campaign payments to relatives during the past three election cycles, from 2001 to 2006. Campaigns paid about $1.6 million to firms owned by or employing the lawmakers or their relatives, the group found...

Melanie Sloan, a former federal prosecutor who heads the watchdog group, says paying relatives with campaign money gives the impression that Congress members use their "position as a profit center for the family."

"A member of Congress would not be allowed to put that family member on their office payroll," Sloan says. "The logic should be the same. If they can't put them on the official payroll, why should they put them on the campaign payroll?"

Sloan says her group started the study last year amid criticism of some members of Congress for their family ties to campaign fundraising. For example, the campaign and political action committee for Rep. John Doolittle, R-Calif., paid a 15% commission to his wife's fundraising business, which also did work for lobbyist Jack Abramoff, who was sentenced to prison last year for fraud. Doolittle stepped down from his committees in April after FBI agents raided his wife's offices in their suburban Washington home. Doolittle is not in the CREW study because he was not a committee or subcommittee leader... (
Full Story)

RELATED RECIPIENTS: Who got paid?

CREW's Full Report: Family Affair



http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/2007-06-17-campaign-funds_N.htm#Close




Detroit Casino Syndicators' Connection
On the CREW lists published in USA Today:
  • Rep. Buck McKeon (R-Ca 25th) whose district includes Barstow, CA and Barstow Mayor Lawrence Dale is his political appointee to the regional GOP committee (his wife has been paid $263,168 funneled through his campaign); and

  • Rep. Bart Stupak (D-Mi 1st) whose district includes the Bay Mills Indian Community and who has sponsored numerous bills to push an off-reservation casino for the Bay Mills Indians (his wife and son have been paid $132,036 from campaign funds).

Michael J. Malik, Sr. and Mrs. Marian Ilitch have bankrolled plans to develop and manage two Indian casinos in Barstow and various casino plans for the Bay Mills Indians the last decade. They've established a track record of contributions totaling $9,000 to Rep. Stupak; but oddly enough, there are no contributions recorded to Barstow area Rep. McKeon.

The pair of Detroit casino syndicators and their family members have contributed generously to other California lawmakers and their causes including:

These disclosures analyzed in the CREW report are made available because campaign committees must report their explenditures to the Federal Elections Commission. However if individuals or organziations lobbying Members of Congress hire or retain the services of a member of that Congressional Representative's family directly and for non-lobbbying and non-political campaign purposes; there is little, if any, disclosure required.

A corporation or individual could retain a Member's son to provide strategic counsel or empty waste baskets and if the son didn't lobby his father, but representatives of the Corporation or the individual employing the son did, payments to the son would not necessarily ever be disclosed. Certainly there's nothing stopping the coporate lobbyists from mentioning to the Member what a "fine job" his/her son is doing on their behalf as they leave the Member of Congress' office.

StumbleUpon Toolbar Stumble It!

Ilitch has own plans for ticket price increases and taxpayer subsidies

Mike Ilitch doesn't want the state to impose a luxury tax or an entertainment surcharge proposed by Gov. Jennifer Granholm and Lansing lawmakers. The new revenue would be used to support a shortfall in education funding and other public services across the state. The state's other option is to raise income taxes for all residents of Michigan.

The 78-year old Ilitch plans his own increase in ticket prices so he can continue to expand his family's vast sports, entertainment, restaurant and gambling empire; and so he can lock in his position on the list of the "400 Richest Americans." The proposal for a luxury tax/entertainment surcharge could mean he might not be able to hike up his own ticket price increases as much as he wants.

Mike Ilitch's grandkids can afford to go to the best private academies. He can pay for their individual education needs. He's more concerned with expanding his Foxtown playground in downtown Detroit than with addressing the shortfall in statewide education funding. It appears he'd rather see an increase in the state's income tax for all working people in Michigan.

According to Forbes magazine, Mike Ilitch is worth $1.5 billion; making him one of the "400 Richest Americans" -- in fact, he ranks at #242 out of 301 million Americans (tied with Oprah Winfrey and several others). Mike Ilitch is the sixth richest person in Michigan, a state of nearly 10 million people.

As the owner of the Detroit Tigers, Detroit Red Wings and numerous other sporting and theater venues; "of course," you might say, "he's opposed to a so-called ticket tax."

It shouldn't be any surprise that Mike Ilitch is behind a so-called "grassroots" campaign and web site to block the proposed luxury tax/entertainment surcharge. Although the bulk of the Ilitch Family's annual income comes from pizza and gambling ventures; the sports and entertainment operations contribute significantly to Ilitch's net worth and personal image. Besides such a "grassroots" campaign is a great way to collect email addresses and other contact data from fans that can be used for future marketing schemes.

But take a closer look. Ticket prices will go up regardless and Ilitch will have benefited from millions in taxpayer subsidies and tax breaks, not Michigan's kids.

So why is Mike Ilitch opposed to an entertainment surcharge at this time?

  1. Because the Ilitch organization has its own ticket price hikes planned, and the market can only take so much. For the 2007 Baseball season the Sports Business News blog indicates Ilitch already hiked up prices 5.2%; and he inflated ticket prices so high during the NHL Playoffs this spring that the Red Wings didn't even sell out their home games in the playoff rounds.

    From Anser Khan's blog Red Wings Bulletin: "Obviously, they miscalculated in setting ticket prices for the playoffs. There’s nothing they can do about it now, but, unless the Wings win the Stanley Cup, they’re going to have to lower ticket prices next season, especially in the playoffs."


  2. Because Ilitch has his own plans for taxpayer dollars. Ilitch wants taxpayers to support a move to abandon Joe Louis Arena and build a new Ilitch Hockey Arena in Foxtown on land Ilitch owns or contrals that will certainly call for taxpayers subsidies and maybe even some new tax. And then, when there's a new fancier, state of the art hockey arena in Detroit he can jack up ticket prices again.

    Shortly after Comerica Park opened, CNN/Sports Illustrated posted an article, New Ballparks lead wave of higher ticket prices, that said:

  3. "The average at Comerica Park is $24.83, the fourth-highest in baseball and a 103 percent jump from the $12.23 average at Tiger Stadium last season, according to the annual survey by the Team Marketing Report." April 4, 2000
    A 2006 study by Economics Research Associates (ERA), an often quoted source, notes:
    "Of 14 teams analyzed, the Detroit Tigers experienced the greatest increase in average ticket price (103 percent)," when Comerica Park opened.
And as the Detroit News reported last fall when the Tigers won the American League Pennant, "Ticket prices soaring" and the Ilitch organization, not the taxpayers, are benefiting.

It is highly rumored and quite likely Mike Ilitch has plans to build a new hockey arena on property he controls in Foxtown -- an area of Downtown Detroit controlled primarily by Ilitch and various city related agencies and authorities -- where:

  • Ilitch Holdings, Inc. has it's corporate headquarters;
  • Ilitch owns/controls venues like the Fox Theater, City Theater and Comerica Park;
  • Ilitch owns restaurants like HockeyTown Cafe, Johnny Rockets, &
    Foxtown Grille
    ;
  • Ilitch owns or controls acres of paid-parking lots; and where,
  • Ilitch, in recent years, has methodically acquired more than 75 properties and often boarded up and then demolished historic buildings to make way for parking lots and future expansions using millions in taxpayer subsidies.
And when the new Ilitch Hockey Arena is built, you can bet Mike Ilitch will raise the price of tickets, parking and a beer -- because cand and he will.Mike Ilitch has used taxpayer subsidies and tax breaks to build his business empire many times over -- at least $90 million on Comerica Park alone; if the state legislature enacts an entertainment surcharge it will be his responsibility and he'll decide whether or not to pass the cost on to fans.

Mike Ilitch doesn't want the state to impose a luxury tax on him; nor does he support an entertainment surcharge to fund education and other services for the taxpayers of Michigan. Ilitch wants to increase ticket prices so he can continue to expand his family's vast sports, entertainment, restaurant and gambling empire and guarantee his position on the list of the "400 Richest Americans."

He's asked the general taxpayers to help pay for his Foxtown playground expansions (and increased traffic cops needed to support his game days) before, isn't it time he started delivering on his promises to have the playground pay back the citizens of Michigan.

Friday, June 15, 2007

Congressional Testimony: Team owners get rich off taxpayers subsidies; while taxpayers see little net return


From official testimony given in

the U.S. House of Representatives
Subcommittee on Domestic Policy,
Committee on Oversight and Government Reform


March 29, 2007

Frank D. Rashid

“…In selling these projects to the public, local officials made plenty of promises about the benefits they would bring: new jobs, economic spin-off from stadium-related activities, contracts for minority firms, increased city revenues for more police and city services.

Not one of these promises has been fulfilled.

In the last two years, the city has hosted major league baseball’s All-Star Game, the Super Bowl, and the World Series, but city residents have seen no lasting benefits from these highly touted events. The city faces a financial crisis, with two consecutive years of deficit and has had to cut police and fire protection, library hours, and trash pickup among other city services.

Comerica Park and Ford Field have been in operation for six and four seasons respectively, but the blessings of major league sports have yet to rain down upon the people of Detroit. The owners of the two teams, on the other hand, have been blessed with dramatically increased franchise value.

They have also taken advantage of the opportunity afforded by the new stadiums to raise ticket prices.

In effect, we gave hundreds of millions of dollars to two billionaires so they could charge higher prices and become even wealthier. This is called urban development...

Full Text of Prepared Testimony

Ilitch behind campaign to stop state luxury tax/ticket surcharge proposal



ClickOnDetroit.com, the website for Detroit's Local4 NBC affiliate WDIV, reports the following:

Local Business Leaders Say No To New Tax

Local business leaders are fighting to stop the new tax plan that will charge people to purchase tickets for sports, entertainment and other luxury items.

Mike Ilitch, owner of the Detroit Tigers, Detroit Red Wings and other venues like the Fox Theatre and Bill Davidson, who owns the Detroit Pistons and several concert venues launched a Web site to get you to speak out about the tax.

Opponents to the tax said it unfairly burdens Detroit, the biggest concert and sports venue area in the state.

According to lawmakers, the luxury tax would bring in an estimated $100 million into the state,


from Ansar Khan's Red Wings Bulletin blog at mlive.com:
"It wasn’t too surprising to see empty seats at Joe Louis Arena in the first round against Calgary, considering the state of the economy in Michigan, the high ticket prices and the team’s string of early playoff exits...Obviously, they miscalculated in setting ticket prices for the playoffs. There’s nothing they can do about it now, but, unless the Wings win the Stanley Cup, they’re going to have to lower ticket prices next season, especially in the playoffs."


ranks Mike Ilitch at #242 (tied with Oprah Winfrey) on its annual list of the "400 Richest Americans."



Ilitch receives $600,000 "Brownfield" tax credit for Detroit Life Building rehab

Michigan business briefs
June 15, 2007


DEVELOPMENT: Brownfield credit OK'd

Plans by the Ilitch family to redevelop the historic but dilapidated Detroit Life building near the Fox Theatre took a big step forward Thursday.

Detroit's Brownfield Redevelopment Authority, a quasi-public arm of the city, approved a $600,000 brownfield tax credit to help pay to clean up the building at 2210 Park Ave. The credit will cover approximately 10% of the estimated $6-million cost of the renovation work.

The brownfield credit is just one piece of a financial package that also will include historical tax credits as well as conventional investment.

Ilitch Holdings, the family's business entity, plans to move some of its subsidiary functions into the building once the renovation work is complete. Plans call for the first floor to contain retail or commercial space, while Floors 2 through 10 would contain office space.

Construction is expected to begin this summer.

Crews from J.C. Beal Demolition had reportedly been managing asbestos removal last fall. Kraemer Design Group have been retained to develop renovation plans.



Official website: Detroit Life Building
Buildings of Detroit: Detroit Building
Wikipedia: Detroit Building



EPA Brownfields Definition

Brownfields: With certain legal exclusions and additions, the term `brownfield site' means real property, the expansion, redevelopment, or reuse of which may be complicated by the presence or potential presence of a hazardous substance, pollutant, or contaminant.


StumbleUpon Toolbar Stumble It!

Thursday, June 14, 2007

Mashpee Wampanoag backers initiated gambling in Detroit but were never licensed

Several of the cental characters involved in the Mashpee Wampanoag deal in Middleborough, Massachusetts have roots in the birth of Detroit's commercial gambling industry.

Herb Strather and Laurence Deitch (Larry Deitch) were early backers of commercial gaming in Detroit. They were members in Atwater Entertainment Associates LLC, an entity that was, through other affiliates, part owner of Detroit Entertainment LLC (d/b/a MotorCity Casino). However, for undisclosed reasons the pair along with several other intial "investors" were forced to divest themselves of interest in MotorCity Casino.

Here's how one media outlet summed it up:

The sale of shares by at least four partners in the MotorCity Casino was approved Monday by the Michigan Gaming Control Board.

The action could clear the way for the casino to open by mid-December.

Although the board discussed the sale in a closed session and would not divulge details about the sales, people familiar with the sales said those selling their shares include:

Herb Strather, one of the founding partners of Atwater Entertainment, which pushed for casinos in Detroit for at least the past six years.

Nellie Varner, Strather's business partner for 20 years, former treasurer of Mayor Dennis Archer's mayoral campaign and fellow founder of Atwater Entertainment.

Mike Malik, a partner in North American Gaming, which manages a casino for an Indian tribe in Manistee.

Larry Deitch, a University of Michigan regent and the lawyer who wrote Proposal E, the 1996 ballot measure that state voters passed to authorize casinos.

Malik, Varner and Strather are members of the 12-member management committee of the casino. All three were instrumental in pushing to get casinos in Detroit.

The three plan to sell their shares after gaming board investigators told them there were problems with their applications for gaming licenses, people familiar with the situation said.

The board has been investigating the MotorCity Casino group for more than a year.

Tangled Web: Malik's alleged mistress admits she committed perjury to shield his assets in divorce proceedings

TVT has obtained Oakland County, MI court documents and more indicating the wife of veteran NBA Player Clifford Robinson (New Jersey Nets) brought a lawsuit suit nearly a year ago against 53-year old Michael J. Malik, Sr.

Heather Lufkins Robinson (a 36-year old who married Robinson in Sept. 2003 and gave birth to their twin sons in 2005) brought suit against defendants Michael Malik, Sr. and his JR Property Holdings, LLC, claiming she held an interest in property owned by JR Property Holdings, LLC located at 1907 W. Houstonia Ave., Royal Oak, MI 48073-3915. The property was previously held by MJM Royal Properties (a Malik controlled entity formed in May 2001).

Lufkins-Robinson alleges she became romantically involved with defendant Michael Malik, Sr. while he was married to another woman (Michele M. Malik – aka Michele Resseguie, Michele Flaum, Michele Flaum-Malik). During that time, the plaintiff moved into a home the defendant had reportedly purchased for his son (from an earlier marriage), 25-year old Michael Malik, Jr. Father and son had formed JR Property Holdings, LLC in August 2001, three months after Malik Sr. established MJM Royal Properties. Malik Sr. signed the annual corporate filing for JR Property Holdings in January 2002 as “manager” of the entity.

During Malik Sr.’s divorce proceedings, Ms. Lufkins-Robinson had testified that Malik Jr. owned the Royal Oak property. At that time, she also signed a handwritten statement before a notary declaring that "Michael Malik owes me nothing and never did."

However, Ms. Lufkins-Robinson obviously decided to come clean a year ago and commenced a lawsuit alleging she was entitled to the property. (sidenote: The NBA suspended Clifford Robinson for five days without pay on drug related charges in May 2006).

In her 2006 complaint, Ms. Lufkins-Robinson admitted her testimony at the Maliks' earlier divorce proceeding was a "scam" to help shield Michael Malik’s assets; and she attached to her 2006 complaint a handwritten letter allegedly signed by defendant Malik Sr., which stated the home was to be given to the her.

Unfortunately for Ms. Lufkins-Robinson, the Oakland County Circuit Court Judge, furious at the games being played, ruled that a plaintiff who perjured herself in a prior proceeding may not later institute a cause of action that conflicts with the previous false testimony and tossed out Ms. Lufkins-Robinson's claim.

In some odd way, it seems the former Mrs. Malik and Ms. Lufkins-Robinson were both victims in this so-called Malik “scam.” Court records reveal, at the end of the day, Mike Malik Sr. and his attorneys were quite pleased with themselves.


ADDITIONAL BACKGROUND
Heather Lufkins Robinson is the daughter of L. John Lufkins, a former chairman of the Bay Mills Indian Community. Reportedly Michael Malik and the Ilitch Family have been bankrolling plans for a Bay Mills Indian Casino in Port Huron, among other locales, for more than a dozen years. John Lufkins was tribal chairman when former Governor John Engler signed a land claims settlement agreement that was intended to pave the way for a Port Huron Casino.

There was conjecture in 1999 that one reason perhaps Michael J. Malik, Sr. wouldn't qualify for a gaming license in Detroit was an earlier arrest on domestic assault charges. In 1997, Malik was arrested and served a years probation on charges he beat up the 12-year old son of a girlfriend; a woman whom he subsequently married and then divorced -- Michele M. Malik (aka Michele Flaum-Malik); the same woman whom it now appears may have been "scammed" in divorce proceedings.


You may also want to review these posts or click on the "labels" below for related information:

Former MotorCity investor Celani opens Okla. casino


6.11.07


Local businessman Tom Celani, a former investor in MotorCity Casino L.L.C., has opened a casino in Carnegie, Okla., in conjunction with the Kiowa Tribe.

The 65,000-square-foot Kiowa Red River Casino features about 1,000 slot machines and more than 20 table games and includes three restaurants.

Red River is expected to generate $70 million in gross revenue in its first 12 months of operation, with the tribe expecting to receive net profit of $100 million in five years, Celani, of Bloomfield Hills, said in a statement. His company Luna Gaming provided financing for the casino.

Celani’s other casino interests are in Rolling Hills Casino, Corning, Calif.; Little River Casino, Manistee; Red Dolly Casino, Black Hawk, Colo.; and Cal Neva Casino, Lake Tahoe, Nev. He also owns MotorCity Harley Davidson in Farmington Hills.

— Robert Ankeny


BACKGROUND
Tom Celani, Marian Ilitch and Michael Malik collectively held 85% interest in Atwater Casino Group (ACG), a collection of Detroit area business leaders who had backed the proposal for three casinos in Detroit.

In 1997, ACG joined together with Circus Circus (later Mandalay Resort Group) to form Detroit Entertainment LLC (DELLC), the company behind MotorCity Casino (a DELLC d/b/a). Celani, Ilitch and Malik collectivelyheld a 35% stake in MotorCity Casino.

In 1999, before MotorCity Casino even opened, several of the ACG local shareholders were disqualified from receiving gaming licenses or otherwise forced to sell their shares including Herb Strather, Nellie Varner, Walter Douglas, Laurence Deitch, James Blain, Ronald Slavic and Malik. All but Malik sold their interests to Mandalay Resort Group.

Malik sold his shares to Ilitch and Celani because the Michigan Gaming Control Board wouldn't grant him a license. Ilitch retained 25% of MotorCity and Celani 10%.

Early in 2005, Ilitch opened negotiations with Mandalay Resort Group and MGM/Mirage to acquire their 53.5% interest in MotorCity Casino; Celani lead the other investors behind ACG and filed suit in February 2005 alleging Marian Ilitch had violated the terms of their partnership agreement by secretly and unilaterally negotiating a deal to purchase Mandalay's stake in the gaming hall. Several months later, the parties settled and Ilitch acquired all outstanding shares of Detroit Entertainment LLC to take 100% control of MotorCity Casino.

You may want to review these posts:

Attorney Dennis Whittlesey to advise Mass. town on casino

About 600 people gathered outside Middleborough High School yesterday for a meeting on a proposed casino. (VINCE DEWITT FOR THE BOSTON GLOBE)

By Christine Wallgren, Globe Correspondent June 14, 2007

MIDDLEBOROUGH -- As residents voiced concerns about having a casino in town, selectmen voted last night to hire a lawyer well known in gaming circles to help them negotiate potential contracts with the Mashpee Wampanoags.

The presence of the lawyer, Dennis Whittlesey, at last night's meeting seemed to calm some residents, who were worried that the town was rushing into a pact without weighing citizen concerns.

Whittlesey applauded the town's attempt to work with the tribe.

"Frankly, once the land goes into trust, there is no obligation for the tribe to work with the community," he said. "It's a tremendous advantage to work on an agreement and walk together with the tribe to the secretary of the interior," who reviews applications to put land into federal trust and thereby remove it from state and local control.

Whittlesey, of the Washington, D.C. firm of Dickinson Wright, was invited to the meeting by Selectman Adam Bond. Whittlesey agreed to help fine-tune a recently produced draft agreement between the town and the tribe for a casino, a process he estimated would take about four weeks.

Officials did not indicate what he would be paid, but they recently got Town Meeting approval for $60,000 for casino-related negotiations... (Full Story)




You may also want to review these posts:

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Middleborough selectmen to vote on hosting Indian casino

The Mashpee Wampanoags meet with Middleborough selectmen tonight to discuss building a casino resort in the southeastern Massachusetts town. The Cape Cod tribe will present local officials with a draft agreement in which the town agrees to host an Indian casino in exchange for $7 million a year over the next ten years. Payment in lieu of taxes.



read more | digg story

Historic Tiger Stadium one step closer to being demolished

6.07.07

Detroit EDC OKs plan to tear down Tiger Stadium

By Aaron Harris

The Detroit Economic Development Corp.’s board approved a plan Thursday to demolish Tiger Stadium.

The board approved the project pending approval from the Detroit City Council. The EDC plans to present its plan to the council in July.

The plan calls for most of the 95-year-old stadium to be demolished to redevelop the site into a mixed-use retail and residential property. The estimated cost is $2.95 million.

To finance the project, the plan calls for Schneider Industries, a St. Louis auction company, to sell stadium memorabilia including seats and locker-room items. If the plan is approved by City Council, Schneider Industries would set up a Web-based memorabilia auction.

“The plan is to tear down the structure and sell the steel,” said Peter Zeiler, EDC business development representative. “But we also want to make sure that we keep some the historic aspects of the stadium in Detroit.”

Zeiler said one of those aspects includes keeping the baseball field for youth baseball leagues.

Ambassador Bridge is ...

6.13.07


Bridges Falling Down

The bridge is owned and operated by the minions of one man, a reclusive Grosse Pointe zillionaire


by Jack Lessenberry

Gregg Ward is a boyish-looking 46-year-old with an interesting and crucial job you've probably never heard of. He and his dad run the Detroit-Windsor Truck Ferry, which since 1990 has been the only approved system for taking trucks carrying hazardous materials across this part of the U.S.-Canada border.

That doesn't mean the Wards take all the hazmat across. They don't. Their one barge is only allowed to operate 10 hours a day. In that time they might transport, at most, 50 trucks.

Meanwhile, something like 9,000 trucks use the Ambassador Bridge daily. Naturally, since they aren't taking Gregg's barge, does that mean they are all hauling frozen spinach and motor mounts? Well, hardly.

Plenty of them carry hazmat too.

You see, the bridge, as noted here on March 7, is not, as you might expect, jointly owned by the two nations. They don't even have any say in running it. Instead, it is owned and operated by the minions of one man, a reclusive Grosse Pointe zillionaire named Manuel "Matty" Moroun.

He believes that he is a law unto himself, at least as far as the bridge is concerned. He doesn't allow either country to inspect it. He does what he wants. "He issues letters to those trucks he owns, and perhaps some others, saying they can take hazmat across," Ward said over lunch in Dearborn. Others have told me the same thing. "I get the leftovers — his competitors, maybe."

That may not be fair, but nobody in authority seems to be willing to challenge the man Forbes Magazine called "The troll under the bridge." (Full Story)




You may also want to review these posts:

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Firm produced valuation of Malik's interest in MotorCity Casino for use in court

from the website of Christiansen Capital Advisors, LLC on the firm's "Background and Experience:"

Litigation Support
Valuation of Motor City Casino as of September 6, 1997
(Michael J. Malik Sr. v. Michelle Flaum-Malik)

Engagement with Ehrlich Foley & Serwer, P.C. included:
  • Formed an opinion of the value of the interest Ehrlich’s client held in the entity that became Motor City Casino during the period 1997-1999, prior to and after the investor divested himself of this interest through its sale.

  • Value the interest Ehrlich’s client held in the entity that became Motor City Casino at the time the investor divested himself of this interest through its sale.

  • Project included expert report and signatory on opinion letter.
    (Deposition taken of Eugene Christiansen.) Settled.
CLIENT:
Joseph H. Ehrlich
Ehrlich Foley & Serwer, P.C.
Wabeek Building
280 West Maple Road, Suite 310
Birmingham, Michigan 48009-3344
Voice: (248) 540-0100



You may also want to review these posts or click on the "labels" below for related information:

TVT has welcomed more than 178,000 unique vistors

TVT, founded in December 2006, has averaged more than 20,000 visitors annually. It is produced with the support of scores of individuals from coast-to-coast, each a volunteer citizen activist/jounalist, who review tips and compile the verifiable details and documents that are the hallmark of our content.

Since our first post, more than 178,000 visitors have accessed the details compiled uniquely at TVT.

The citizen activists behind TVT wish to extened a big "THANK YOU" to all those who have provided "tips" -- contributed pictures, documents, link suggestions, leads, reports, insight and comments. Your trust and confidence in TVT has allowed us to create a comprehensive resource that thousands of others -- including bloggers, journalists, Members of Congress and other local citizen activists around the country -- have come to rely upon.

We invite feedback and constructive comment and want you to know you are welcome to do that here in "comments" or by contacting us directly and confidentially via allverifiable@gmail.com

Google News: Indian Gaming

NEWS: Bay Mills Indian Community & Casino Proposals

NEWS: Shinnecock Indian Nation (Gateway Casino Resorts) Casino Proposals

NY Times: Shinnecock Indian Nation

NEWS: Los Coyotes Indian Tribe

NEWS: Los Coyotes / Barwest Barstow Casino Proposals

NEWS: Michael J. Malik, Sr.

NEWS: Marian Ilitch

Muckety.com: Mapping Social Networks

Play with the interactive tool here or visit Muckety.com

TIP: Search for multiple entries in the Muckety.com database simultaneously by separating their names with the word and

certainly must reads!

● Ilitch has backed loosing sports teams and pizza, but casinos in Detroit? Forbes.com 10.09.06 ● Marian Ilitch #1 on "25 Most Powerful People" to Watch 2006” global gaming business o1.oo.o5 ● My Kingdom for a Casino Forbes 05.08.06 ● Big Lagoon’s casino dream awakens north coast journal 07.28.05 ● Shinnecocks launch legal claim to Hamptons land newsday.com 06.16.05 ● Ilitch Plans to Expand Casino Empire RGTonline.com 07.05.05 ● Ilitch outbids partners MichiganDaily.com 04.14.05 ● Ilitch enmeshed in NY casino dispute detnews.com 03.20.05 ● Marian Ilitch, high roller freep.com 03.20.05 ● MGM Mirage to Decide on Offer for Casino in Detroit rgtonline.com 04.16.05 ● Secret deal for MotorCity alleged freep.com 02.15.05 ● Los Coyotes get new developer desertdispatch.com 02.08.05 ● Detroit casino figure to finance Barstow project LasVegasSun.com 07.07.03 ● Indian Band trying to put casino in Barstow signonSanDiego.com 06.04.03 ● Pizza matriarch takes on casino roles detnews.com 10.23.02 ● Vanderbilt gets short straw in negotiations for a casino Lansing Journal 10.06.02 ● Indians aim to drive family from tribe in vicious dispute san diego union tribune 04.09.00 ●Malik owns 2000 Michigan Quarter Horse of the Year Michigan.gov 01.01.00 ● Detroit Team to run Michigan’s newest Indian casino detnews.com 05.23.99 ● Tiger ties tangle Marian Ilitch detnews.com 04.29.99 ● Three investors must sell their Detroit casino interests gamblingmagazine.com 04.25.99 ● Partners’ cash revived election; They say money was crucial to Prop-E detnews.com 04.25.99 ● Investors have troubled histories las vegas review journal 04.27.99 ● Investor served probation for domestic assault on 12 year old boy detnews.com 04.25.99 ● Can a pair win a jackpot?: local men hope to... crainsdetroit.com 03.17.97

The Verifiable Truth