Thursday, June 26, 2008

Harsens Island Marina project has no public support

6.26.08

Harsens Island residents oppose development

By BOB GROSS

About 145 people attended a public hearing on Tuesday at Algonac High School to talk about a marina permit for a proposed 348-unit cluster housing development on the former Boys Club property on Harsens Island.
The developers, Grande Pointe Development and Lucky 7 Development LLC, applied May 1 for a marina operating permit from the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality.

About 25 people spoke at the hearing, said Alice Szulborski, who lives near the proposed development and attended the meeting. An official with the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality could not be reached for comment.

"Not one person spoke up in favor of it," she said. "If there was someone in favor of it sitting there, I don't know. No one spoke up."

Many island residents concerned about the effect on the island oppose the development.

Timothy Stoepker, a lawyer with Dickinson Wright PLLC in Grand Rapids, gave a presentation for the developer during the hearing.

"Normally people who oppose are the ones who show up," he said. "People who are in support of change do not show up. Typically in land use matters, no one supports change. It's rare."

On Feb. 27, the Clay Township Planning Commission rejected a special land-use request that would have allowed construction of the project. Grande Pointe and Lucky 7, managed and owned by former Clay Township resident Michael Malik, filed an appeal of the decision March 19 in St. Clair County Circuit Court.

Gary Fletcher, a Port Huron lawyer representing the developers, did not attend Tuesday's meeting -- which did not address the planning commission decision. He said the developers and the township will submit briefs for the appeal in the next 60 days.

Developers need a permit from the DEQ to construct and operate a marina with 344 slips for the use of property owners and an additional 18 slips for day use. They propose to dredge out a marina basin on the former Boys Club property that would connect with the North Channel of the St. Clair River.

Developers also propose moving the existing riverfront road.

Szulborski, who said she has been visiting Harsens Island for about 60 years and has lived there year-round the past 15 years, said the project doesn't fit DEQ criteria for a marina operating permit.

She said it unreasonably affects the public trust "because they plan on taking out the road and the waterfront property on the other side of the road, which they don't own.

"The egress and ingress also is going to be on public property," she said

She said a new marina in the area also will increase boat congestion on the North Channel and the development does not fit in with surrounding residences.

"I'm not against developing the area," she said. "I'm not against homes being put there. I am against a 60-acre lagoon being dug there. I am against my road being taken out."

But Stoepker said the project should receive a permit.

"From our position this project meets all the requirements under the applicable statute for approval and under the applicable rules," he said.

Wednesday, June 25, 2008

What does Marian Ilitch see in Mike Malik?

What does Marian Ilitch see in Mike Malik (Michael J. Malik, Sr.) other than millions of dollars of her family's money being flushed down the drain?

For more than a decade Malik's found some way to convince Marian Ilitch to invest millions in her family's fortune on his various casino schemes. O.K. so she's now the owner of Detroit's MotorCity Casino -- presumably an opportunity originally brought to her by Malik and his associates -- but Malik has failed in every effort to develop a new casino since then:
  • Failed to legalize gambling in Hawaii and build a proposed casino resort on Oahu;


  • Failed multiple times to get state or federal approvals for various schemes to build Indian casinos in Barstow, California;


  • Failed to make any meaningful progress on a scheme to build an Indian casino in the posh Hamptons resort on New York's Long Island; and today,


  • Failed for the seventh time in ten years to win congressional approvals for a scheme manufactured for the opportunity to build an off-reservation casino in Port Huron, Michigan.
In fact, the only success Malik has with casino resort projects dates back to the 1990s when he worked with a partner, Tom Celani. On the other hand, Celani has gone on to greatly expand his interests in casino and resort projects across the U.S.

Where does Rep. Bart Stupak come up with this stuff?

An article published 6.25.08 in the Detroit News announcing the sound defeat of bills that would have paved the way for an expansion of off-reservation Indian casinos in Michigan reads:

"Rep. Bart Stupak, D-Menominee, said non-Indian homeowners at Charlotte Beach have seen their property values assessed at 90 percent below value because of the legal cloud over the land. "
Rep. Stupak should surface the basis for his comments. And he should report when it was that he received such "facts."

Could it have been during the brief period back in the late 1990s when the Bay Mills Indian Community filed court action on their so-called land claims? Because those claims were subsequently tossed out by both state and federal courts seemingly clearing the sky of any "clouds" over title to local land. And there seems to be no public record of concerned property owners since then. Documents filed for local real estate transactions don't support Stupak's representations either.

During congressional hearings in recent years on the matter there were never any Charlotte Beach landowners who testified. Nor did anyone representing any collection of property owners appear.

There has been no grassroots advocacy on behalf of the "agrieved" property owners in the 110-acre Charlotte Beach subdivision located on Michigan's eastern Upper Penninsula, with one exception: Detroit casino syndicator Michael Malik.

But in fact, Malik, the businessman who has a financial interest in advancing the settlement scheme has acquired and sold land in Charlotte Beach at a profit. What would have compelled a businessman like Malik to buy Charlotte Beach land at a price greater than what the previous owner had paid just several years prior; and then enabled Malik to turn around and sell it to someone else at a profit a short time later. Hhhmmmmm?

Shame on Stupak's staff, they should really do a better job arming their boss with facts they've gathered independently.

Rep. Stupak should get current and come clean about his representations and what he would imply are "facts." Relying soley on what casino syndicator Mike Malik and his battalion of attorneys and lobbyists have represented isn't smart. And certainly relying on a factoid someone tossed in his lap nearly ten years ago isn't smart either.

See the following posts for more details:

Port Huron casino scheme defeated in House of Representatives

A bill, H.R. 2176, that would have paved the way for Michael Malik and the Bay Mills Indian Community to build an off-reservation casino in Port Huron, Michigan was defeated soundly today in the U.S. House of Representatives (121 to 298).

Malik and the Bay Mills tribe have been trying to site an off-reservation casino in the greater Detroit area for more than a decade. Their plans have been backed by members of Detroit's high-profile Ilitch family. Mrs. Marian Ilitch owns Detroit's MotorCity Casino.

Malik had originally been a partner in MotorCity Casino but the Michigan Gaming Control Board (MGCB) refused to grant a gaming license to Malik. He was forced to divest himself of interests in MotorCity Casino before the gambling hall could open its doors. Malik and members of the Ilitch family have also partnered on other Indian casino schemes in California and New York. Although apparently not employed today by Ilitch Holdings, Inc., or any of its affiliates, Malik's business office is within the suite of executive offices at Ilitch Holdings in Detroit's Fox Theater Building.

Over the last decade, at least six other bills similar to H.R. 2176 have been introduced, but failed to win approvals, in Congress. This was the first time such a bill moved out of committee and was submitted to a vote of the full House.

House rules outlining today's floor debate on off-reservation casinos narrowly pass

An update posted at the Port Huron Times Herald regarding the status of today's anticipated vote on H.R. 2176 in the U.S House of Representatives:

The U.S. House has passed the rules outlining the debate about the casino bills [H.R. 2176 & H.R. 4115] up for vote today. The rules passed 207-204, and the legislation that would pave the way for casinos in Port Huron and Romulus is to be discussed this afternoon. Earlier reports on CSPAN that the legislation had been ratified were incorrect.

H.R. 2176 is a bill that paves the way for Michael Malik and the Bay Mills Indian Community to build an off-reservation Indian casino in Port Huron, Michigan. H.R. 4115 paves the way for the Sault Ste. Marie tribe (owners of Detroit's commercial Greektown Casino, a facility currently in bankruptcy) to build an off-reservation Indian casino in either Romulus or Flint, Michigan.

If passed in the House of Represenatives today the bills move to the Senate where the process starts all over. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) opposes the bill. Previously GOP presidential candidate Senator John McCain (R-AZ) has opposed similar attempts by these tribes and their financial backers.

Tuesday, June 24, 2008

Controversial schemes for off-reservation casinos in Michigan set for vote on House floor

6.24.08

Pelosi to grant vote on Indian gaming bill benefiting Rep. Dingell’s district

By Susan Crabtree

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) is giving Rep. John Dingell (D-Mich.) a full House vote Wednesday on a nettlesome Indian gaming bill he’s been pushing for years as a surefire way to help out his cash-strapped district.

Dingell and his allies tried — albeit unsuccessfully — to insert it into various legislative vehicles despite an onslaught of complaints from high-profile opponents and others, such as convicted lobbyist Jack Abramoff, who were stalwartly against congressional intervention in the issue.

Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), then the chairman of the Senate Indian Affairs panel investigating Abramoff’s Indian gambling lobbying scandal, was infuriated by an effort to parachute the language into an early version of the 2005 highway bill. Rep. Don Young (R-Alaska), at Dingell’s urging, had placed the language deep within the massive transportation measure as early as 2003.

Rep. Richard Pombo (R-Calif.), the House Natural Resources chairman, also objected. Both he, and especially McCain, were incensed that Dingell and Young were bypassing their committees of jurisdiction, as well as what they regarded as the normal Department of the Interior approval of Indian issues involving casino interests.

In fact, to make the Indian land settlement claim language even less noticeable, Young and Dingell collaborated on language that would make it appear transportation-related.

According to draft language offered by Dingell, the provisions would appropriate $100,000 for two traffic studies to be conducted in Port Huron and Romulus, Mich., in connection with “economic development” that may result from the resolution of two tribes’ land-settlement claims. Language embedded in the provision approved them and directed the secretary of the Interior to take the land into trust.

Critics, including powerful Detroit Democratic Reps. John Conyers Jr. and Carolyn Kilpatrick, sniffed out the language, and drove their point home by arguing that the deals the bills cut for the Bay Mills and Sault Ste. Marie tribes would side step the careful federal consideration that is usually required and set a dangerous Congressional precedent for other tribes around the country. Conyers and Kilpatrick are concerned that the new nearby casinos would draw customers and revenue away from Detroit while generating no tax revenue for the state because Indian gaming operations aren’t taxed.

Casino developers negotiated with the tribes and lawmakers, and the cities of Romulus, in Dingell’s district, and Port Huron, in Rep. Candice Miller’s (R-Mich.), which were selected because they were close enough to Detroit to attract tourists and visitors.

The lawmakers welcomed the economic lift the gaming business would bring to the sagging rust-belt economies of their districts and went to work to get congressional approval. That was nearly a decade ago.

Pombo was the first to object publicly, and McCain stepped in when he heard a return to the earlier shenanigans could take place during the closed-door conference on the 2005 transportation bill.

“I have been informed that other conferees may seek to include in the conference report a provision relating to Indian gaming in Michigan,” McCain wrote in a 2005 letter to Sen. James Inhofe (R-Okla.), chairman of the Committee on Environment and Public Works, which was overseeing the highway bill. “I have been informed that other conferees may seek to include in the conference report a provision relating to Indian gaming in Michigan. Such inclusion would not only circumvent the normal administrative process by which Indian gaming operations are assessed, but also circumvent the regular legislative process for considering exceptions to this process.”

“I appreciate your assistance in keeping such a non-germane issue out of the highway bill,” he continued.

Even though it’s three years later and Democrats now control the majorities in both chambers of Congress, Young — now the ranking member of the Natural Resources Committee — and Dingell are continuing to work together to push the measure over a final finish line. Mike Malik, a casino developer, recently hired Rick Alcalde, one of Young’s “A-List” lobbyists whom interns were told to put through to aides whenever he called, according to a memo crafted by interns.

Even if it passes, however, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.), whose district is home to MGM and other Vegas money, strongly opposes the measure and could prevent it from ever making it to the floor.

MGM owns the largest casino in Detroit and its lobbying against the legislation has been fierce.

The Sault Ste. Marie tribe owns six casinos, one of which — Greektown — pulled in more than $341 million in 2007. The Bay Mills tribe also owns a casino, but it pulls in far less than the Sault Ste. Marie.

Earlier this week, House Natural Resources Chairman Nick Rahall (D-W.Va.) and Young, its ranking member, sent out a “Dear Colleague” letter promoting the measure and trying to poke holes in their critics’ arguments. Two governors specifically chose these sites to settle tribal claims that are more than a hundred years old, they wrote, and both Michigan senators also support it.

It’s difficult to figure out whether Pelosi’s allowance of a more transparent vote on the House floor will make a difference in whether the legislation passes. Both sides are whipping hard, although Pelosi and the rest of the Democratic leaders are staying out of the hunt. The leadership also offered Conyers an amendment, which he could fashion as a poison bill to the underlying bill.

The issue is even dividing the usually solid Congressional Black Caucus (CBC). Twenty-two CBC members had signed a previous letter Conyers had circulated opposing the legislation, while 11 members lent their names to a Dingell letter supporting it.

“We didn’t want there to be a perception that the CBC was of one mind on this,” said one Democratic aide.

Rep. John Conyers: No special deals for tribal casinos

6.24.08


No special deals for tribal casinos

I would like to add a few points concerning the upcoming vote in Congress on legalizing off-reservation casinos in Romulus and Port Huron ("Legislators, tribes divided over casinos; At issue: Romulus, Port Huron sites," June 22):

The validity of the land claims the bills purport to "settle" is questionable. The Bay Mills Indian Community filed its claim in federal and Michigan courts, and lost in both. The Sault Ste. Marie tribe has never bothered to pursue the established legal paths available for settling such claims.

The settlements are for land hundreds of miles from the tribes' reservations. Under the established procedures for considering permitting a tribe to build an off-reservation casino, distance from the reservation is a major factor weighing against approval, because the detriment to the tribe is more likely to outweigh any benefits.

Other important factors under the established procedure are the potential environmental problems and the potential detrimental effects on the surrounding community. The deals the bills cut for the Bay Mills and Sault Ste. Marie tribes would circumvent every part of the careful consideration that is usually required.

In 1993, the two tribes signed a compact with other Michigan tribes in which the signatories agreed to share revenues from any off-reservation gaming facility. The bills pending in Congress allow Bay Mills and Sault Ste. Marie to sidestep that compact.

Michigan voters approved a referendum in 2004 to limit the spread of casinos in their state. These bills would legalize new casinos in defiance of the express wishes of Michigan voters.

Opposition to the bills extends far beyond Detroit's local elected officials and its congressional representatives. It includes more than 60 Indian tribes in Michigan and across the country, all of whom have their own interest in being able to build casinos on their own lands, but who are unified in their opposition to this effort to circumvent the law and the free-for-all it could unleash.

The bills are also opposed by the NAACP, which is concerned that both these bills raise serious questions regarding procedural fairness, due process and respect for the role of states and local governments, as well the voters in our country.

The House Judiciary Committee, which shares jurisdiction over these bills with the Natural Resources Committee, voted unanimously to oppose them.

I believe that by passing the bills favoring the narrow interests of the Bay Mills and Sault Ste. Marie tribes and their private-sector allies, Congress would set a dangerous precedent for sidestepping the established review process for land claims and create a shortcut for the opening of casinos in any corner of the country. The tribes should be allowed to pursue their claims through the normal procedures, including approval by Michigan voters, but not by special deals in Lansing and Washington.

John Conyers Jr.
Chairman
U.S. House Judiciary Committee
Detroit

Monday, June 23, 2008

Lobbyist Rick Alcalde is at the center of earmark controversy involving Rep. Don Young

as reported 5.02.08 by Senior Editor Susan Crabtree of The Hill:

"The earmark has been tainted by controversy. Lobbyist Rick Alcalde represented both FGSU [Florida Gulf State University] as well as the company owned by Daniel Aronoff, a real estate developer who owned 4,000 acres along Coconut Road and helped organize a fundraiser for Young during one of his visits to the area in 2005. Both entities requested the Coconut Road earmark." ... "Young flew to FGSU for a town hall meeting in 2005 on a chartered plane owned by a Michigan company; the owner told the Naples Daily News that the Aronoffs were among his biggest clients." ... "After the town hall, Young went directly to a fundraiser at the Hyatt Coconut Point, which Aronoff helped organize." ... "Young said Mack invited him to the town hall meeting." ... "Young also posted documents and photos on his website in an effort to demonstrate that Mack was deeply involved in the earmark. In one letter in March 2006 to FGSU’s president, Mack supported it."
Detroit-based casino syndicator Michael J. Malik, Sr. is another client of Alcalde's. Malik and his partner Mrs. Marian Ilitch are backing Indian casino proposals in California, Michigan and New York that have come or will come before the House Natural Resources Committee -- a committee once chaired by Rep. Young. Young is currently ranking member on the Natural Resources Committee.

Like Aronoff, Malik and Ilitch are from Michigan; have raised a substantial amount of money for Young; have flown Young around in private/chartered aircraft; and have Young's backing of a controversial off-reservation casino bill (H.R. 2176) that could bring millions to the Detroit casino syndicators.

Malik retained the services of Alcalde after Malik's previous lobbyist, Barbara Bonfiglio, came under intense scrutiny, left her firm abruptly (Williams & Jensen) and went into hiding. Alcalde and Bonfiglio had ties to Rep. Jerry Lewis (former chair of the House Appropriations Committee), former Rep. Richard Pombo, Tom DeLay, Young and others.

Shinnecock make claims of big economic windfall from proposed Long Island casino

From the Weblog of Legislator Wayne Horsley 5.14.08:

Shinnecock Indian Nation Claims Gaming Could Equal 10,200 Jobs, $838 Million in Local Employment, and $4.2 Billion in New Revenue

Hauppauge, New York – Today, Suffolk County Legislator Wayne R. Horsley announced the findings of a series of economic reports presented by the Shinnecock Indian Nation Gaming Authority and the Connecticut Center for Economic Analysis to the Legislature’s Economic Development committee.

The Shinnecock Indian Nation reports revealed a staggering influx of new jobs and revenues would result to the local economy if a Native American gaming establishment were built on Long Island. The research demonstrated that 10, 200 in new jobs, $445 million in new local employment salaries, and over $2.5 billion in new revenue to local and state governments would result. Horsley noted that though a controversial topic in the past, such a proposal merits at least cursory examination as the local economy continues to soften.

“As the local economy continues to soften, we thought it would be worth while to examine the economic benefits of a gaming establishment here on Long Island. After all, we currently contribute to the staggering $234 million in estimated out-of-state gaming funds enjoyed by Connecticut State residents. So the question is why not take a hard look at what the benefits would be if we stopped riding the ferry and started spending our money here on Long Island. In our economy.”

The Shinnecock Nation detailed the employment impact of a sizable gaming establishment: 303 in wholesale and warehouse employment, 654 in retail trade employment, 113 new information service positions, 347 in finance and real estate employment, 369 in professional, scientific, and technical services employment, 453 in management and administrative support jobs, a whopping 820 new education, health care and social assistance positions, and 529 careers in arts, recreation and other services.

A grand total of 3, 817 in non-gaming employment would be produced as a secondary benefit of a Shinnecock Indian Nation gaming establishment. Local purchases made by the gaming establishment would also result in $581 million in new revenue to existing local businesses.

Horsley concluded by saying of the Shinnecock Indian Nation Proposal, “There is no shovel in the ground, and there remains many, many obstacles to such a proposal. So NIMBY’s needn’t be alarmed. However, as our sales tax revenue continues to soften and the local economy dwindles it seems only logical that our committee examine any proposal that may bring as much as $4.2 billion to the Long Island economy.”

Horsley's Official Press Release

This proposal by the Shinnecock Indian Nationa to build a casino in The Hamptons on New York's Long Island is backed by Detroit-based Gateway Casino Resorts -- an enterprise created by casino syndicator Michael J. Malik, Sr. and Mrs. Marian Ilitch. She is the wife of Mike Ilitch who owns the Detroit Tigers. She owns Detroit's MotorCity Casino. Mike and Marian Ilitch are co-founders of Little Caesars Pizza and they also own the Detroit Red Wings.

The so-called findings of the economic analysis mentioned in Horsley's blog suggest the casino resort project being proposed by Gateway (Ilitch/Malik) and the Shinnecock tribe would be much larger than previously disclosed.

Report in Suffolk Life on news related to the study.

Sunday, June 22, 2008

Michigan legislators, tribes divided over casinos in state backed by Ilitch

Excerpt from a 6.22.08 article, written by Todd Spangler and published in the Detroit News:

Michigan legislators, tribes divided over casinos in state

...Michael Malik, the developer who has been working with Bay Mills for years on the Port Huron project, is an associate of Marian Ilitch, who owns MotorCity Casino. The Port Huron project is clearly getting Ilitch family support, if not direct involvement -- since that wouldn't be allowed under Detroit's agreement with MotorCity.

Malik has hired Washington lobbyist Richard Alcalde, who also works for Daniel Aronoff, a Birmingham developer. Newspaper reports have linked Aronoff and Alcalde to the controversial $10-million Coconut Road earmark in Florida -- promoted by Alaska Republican Don Young -- which may benefit one of Aronoff's developments.

Young is the ranking Republican on the Natural Resources Committee and supported the casino bills when they were passed by the committee in February. Malik contributed $4,600 -- the limit -- to Young's re-election committee on March 31. (Full Story)

UAW other labor organizations back off-reservation casino scheme

A press release distributed 6.20.08 by the Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians reads:

In a letter sent today to members of the U.S. House, the UAW said it "strongly supports" H.R. 4115 and H.R. 2176 because the legislation would create jobs, keep gaming revenues in the United States, and provide a much needed economic boost to the communities where the new casinos would open. The UAW also noted that the bills are consistent with state law in Michigan and with past land claim settlements approved by Congress for other tribes.

"For all of the foregoing reasons, the UAW strongly supports H.R. 2176 and H.R. 4115," the union said in its letter. "We urge you to vote for these bills when they are considered by the House and to oppose any weakening amendments."


H.R. 2176
H.R. 4115

Saturday, June 21, 2008

Ilitch partner hired lobbyists involved in congressional earmark scandal: Rep. Young - Coconut Rd., Florida

A Susan Crabtree, senior editor at The Hill, reports that Richard Alcalde, a lobbyist for Detroit casino syndicator Michael J. Malik, Sr., (Ilitch family gambling development partner) is in the middle of a political scandal involving Rep. Don Young.

Malik and Alcalde both have ties to Young. Malik and his casino development partners (members of Detroit's Ilitch family) have been among the Alaska Congressman's top political donors; and Malik's flown Young around on the Ilitch private jet.

Young has helped Malik and the Ilitch family advance casino gambling ventures in Congress. Malik retained Richard Alcalde after a previous lobbyist, Barbara Bonfiglio, came under negative scrutiny.

The Hill reports:
"In April, a casino developer behind the push to settle the land claims through an act of Congress hired Rick Alcalde, a lobbyist implicated in the uproar over a disputed $10 million earmark sponsored by Rep. Don Young (R-Alaska) for an interchange at Coconut Road along Interstate 75 in Florida.

"MJM Enterprises, a company owned by Mike Malik, a casino developer who wants the land disputes settled so he can build a casino in Port Huron, Mich., hired Alcalde in the middle of a public call for a DoJ investigation into the Coconut Road earmark that was taking place in the Senate, lobbying records show.

"Alcalde is one of Young’s group of “A-list” lobbyists, on which The Hill reported in Thursday’s issue."

Funny business in D.C. lobbying reports by those backing Port Huron off-reservation casino scheme

With the funny business in lobbying reporting by individuals including former House Natural Resources Committee Aide Thomas "Tom" Brierton (he worked under former Rep. Richard Pombo, Rep. Don Young and others); are those behind Michael J. Malik, Sr.'s suspect Charlotte Beach Indian land claims and scheme for an off-reservation casino in Port Huron, Michigan, pushing hard for a floor vote in the House before the 2nd quarter lobbying disclosure reports are due?

Lobbyist for off-reservation casino scheme finally discloses former affiliation with House Natural Resources Committee

Tom Brierton, a one time senior aide to former Rep. Richard Pombo, Rep. Don Young and others has been lobbying in support of H.R. 2176, a bill that would allow a Detroit casino syndicator Michael J. Malik, Sr., to finally build an off-reservation casino in Port Huron, Michigan.

While Brierton had been lobbying for Malik since at least the beginning of February, he didn't report he had been retained by Malik's MJM Enterprises (Blue Water Resorts) until 6.13.08. In that disclosure document, Brierton failed to disclose he was at one time a senior staffer to the House Natural Resources Committee. Back in February, the Natural Resources Committee voted in favor of H.R. 2176.

Brierton only filed lobbying disclosures after TVT reported rumors on 6.11.08 that Brierton, a one-time aide to former Rep. Pombo and Rep. Don Young, had been lobbying hard in the House of Representatives for support of H.R. 2176.

However, in quarterly reports required of Capitol Hill lobbyists and filed by Brierton on 6.17.08, Brierton indicates that he was previously a senior policy advisor to the House Resources Committee. First Quarter Lobbying reports were due in April; but Brierton didn't file until June.

Brierton's disclosures come four months after his former colleagues voted in support of H.R. 2176 -- at least four and a half months after he started lobbying House offices in favor of H.R. 2176.

Congress to vote on Michigan land claim scheme; DOJ likely to investigate

6.19.08

Conyers, Dingell gaming dispute to be settled on House floor

By Susan Crabtree

House Democratic leaders have brokered a deal to bring to the floor next week a contentious Indian gaming bill that has pitted two powerful Democratic committee chairmen against one another.

For months, Judiciary Committee Chairman John Conyers Jr. (D-Mich.) and Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman John Dingell (D-Mich.) have been clashing over two bills that would settle tribal land disputes and allow two new Indian casinos to be built near Detroit. Next week, they will settle their differences on the House floor.

The deal would allow the two tribal land dispute bills that Dingell supports to be voted on on the floor, but would also give Conyers an amendment, according to sources tracking the measures. The amendment apparently would direct the Department of Justice (DoJ) and possibly the Department of the Interior to review the land claims — a difficult and likely unsuccessful process Dingell and other supporters have attempted to avoid by seeking congressional approval of the legislation.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and other Democratic leaders are in a politically difficult spot.

They have decided to allot precious floor time for measures that will pave the way for Indian casinos during the first election year after the fall of Jack Abramoff, whose lobbying practices involving tribes and gambling helped propel Democrats into power in 2006.

Opponents of the new casinos, including a diverse bipartisan group headed by Conyers, as well as Rep. Carolyn Kilpatrick (D-Mich.), believe the land claims are illegitimate and will not survive a review by those federal agencies.

Conyers, who opposes gambling on principle, also worries that the new casinos will undermine existing gambling operations that are a major source of tax revenue for cash-strapped Detroit. He and Kilpatrick, the chairwoman of the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC), represent Detroit, but are enlisting the help of other gambling opponents such as Rep. Mike Rogers (R-Mich.). They are making the case that the land claims will set a dangerous precedent for Indian tribes and casino interests across the country.

Dozens of lobbying groups on both sides of the issue are pouring money and resources into a final push to persuade lawmakers on the issue.

In April, a casino developer behind the push to settle the land claims through an act of Congress hired Rick Alcalde, a lobbyist implicated in the uproar over a disputed $10 million earmark sponsored by Rep. Don Young (R-Alaska) for an interchange at Coconut Road along Interstate 75 in Florida.

MJM Enterprises, a company owned by Mike Malik, a casino developer who wants the land disputes settled so he can build a casino in Port Huron, Mich., hired Alcalde in the middle of a public call for a DoJ investigation into the Coconut Road earmark that was taking place in the Senate, lobbying records show.

Alcalde is one of Young’s group of “A-list” lobbyists, on which The Hill reported in Thursday’s issue.

On the other side of the issue, MGM, a major casino presence in Las Vegas, is furiously lobbying against the passage of the two settlement claims because it wants to protect a Detroit casino it built just a few years ago.

The Port Huron casino would help boost the economy in that area, and its congresswoman, Rep. Candice Miller (R-Mich.), has spent years trying to resolve the land dispute claim so her district can have a casino and compete with a Canadian gambling operation located right across the border. Miller and Dingell, whose district would also get a casino out of the deal in the town of Romulus, argue that denying their areas the economic boon the gaming establishments would provide is unfair and motivated by greed.

Conyers, along with Rogers, sent a letter to colleagues Thursday, urging them to reject what they regard as an unprecedented expansion of “off-reservation” Indian gambling. The tribes want the rights to land some 350 miles from their reservations so they can open the casinos in locations where they’re likely to attract more customers, along the border and near Detroit.

Fifty-three House members signed Conyers’s letter, including 22 members of the CBC and 16 Republicans.

“The tribes’ effort to bypass the regular application process is particularly audacious considering the level of opposition these casino proposals face,” Conyers argued. “The Department of the Interior, the Judiciary Committee and the voters of the state of Michigan have all strongly rejected efforts to sidestep the established approval process.”

The letter also stressed that the bills would change the way casinos are approved by allowing Congress to wade into a land dispute that the Department of the Interior routinely determines.

Dingell, a 27-term veteran of the House and its longest-serving member, has joined forces with Natural Resources panel Chairman Nick Rahall (D-W.Va.) and Young, the panel’s ranking member, along with a bipartisan group of Michigan lawmakers, to push for the bills.

Rahall’s committee approved the measures by a wide margin earlier this year, but Conyers followed with a lopsided vote against them in the Judiciary Committee arguing against Congress’s intervention in the matter. Conyers used that Judiciary Committee stamp of disapproval to convince Democratic leaders to give him an amendment, and he hopes it helps stir opposition once it reaches the House floor for a full vote.

Miller also has sent out “Dear Colleague” letters to members.

The land settlement claims, she said, were hashed out by former Michigan Gov. John Engler (R) and approved by the current governor, Jennifer Granholm (D). The newest deal, which Granholm signed off on, would increase the state’s share of gaming revenues by as much as $30 million a year.

She said both Democratic senators from Michigan, Carl Levin and Debbie Stabenow, support the legislation, although she did not mention that Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.), who represents gambling-rich Las Vegas, opposes it.

“This is purely greed,” she said of her opponents’ motivation. “It’s not based on any real anti-gambling philosophy. They’re just trying to protect MGM’s interests.”

TVT has welcomed more than 178,000 unique vistors

TVT, founded in December 2006, has averaged more than 20,000 visitors annually. It is produced with the support of scores of individuals from coast-to-coast, each a volunteer citizen activist/jounalist, who review tips and compile the verifiable details and documents that are the hallmark of our content.

Since our first post, more than 178,000 visitors have accessed the details compiled uniquely at TVT.

The citizen activists behind TVT wish to extened a big "THANK YOU" to all those who have provided "tips" -- contributed pictures, documents, link suggestions, leads, reports, insight and comments. Your trust and confidence in TVT has allowed us to create a comprehensive resource that thousands of others -- including bloggers, journalists, Members of Congress and other local citizen activists around the country -- have come to rely upon.

We invite feedback and constructive comment and want you to know you are welcome to do that here in "comments" or by contacting us directly and confidentially via allverifiable@gmail.com

Google News: Indian Gaming

NEWS: Bay Mills Indian Community & Casino Proposals

NEWS: Shinnecock Indian Nation (Gateway Casino Resorts) Casino Proposals

NY Times: Shinnecock Indian Nation

NEWS: Los Coyotes Indian Tribe

NEWS: Los Coyotes / Barwest Barstow Casino Proposals

NEWS: Michael J. Malik, Sr.

NEWS: Marian Ilitch

Muckety.com: Mapping Social Networks

Play with the interactive tool here or visit Muckety.com

TIP: Search for multiple entries in the Muckety.com database simultaneously by separating their names with the word and

certainly must reads!

● Ilitch has backed loosing sports teams and pizza, but casinos in Detroit? Forbes.com 10.09.06 ● Marian Ilitch #1 on "25 Most Powerful People" to Watch 2006” global gaming business o1.oo.o5 ● My Kingdom for a Casino Forbes 05.08.06 ● Big Lagoon’s casino dream awakens north coast journal 07.28.05 ● Shinnecocks launch legal claim to Hamptons land newsday.com 06.16.05 ● Ilitch Plans to Expand Casino Empire RGTonline.com 07.05.05 ● Ilitch outbids partners MichiganDaily.com 04.14.05 ● Ilitch enmeshed in NY casino dispute detnews.com 03.20.05 ● Marian Ilitch, high roller freep.com 03.20.05 ● MGM Mirage to Decide on Offer for Casino in Detroit rgtonline.com 04.16.05 ● Secret deal for MotorCity alleged freep.com 02.15.05 ● Los Coyotes get new developer desertdispatch.com 02.08.05 ● Detroit casino figure to finance Barstow project LasVegasSun.com 07.07.03 ● Indian Band trying to put casino in Barstow signonSanDiego.com 06.04.03 ● Pizza matriarch takes on casino roles detnews.com 10.23.02 ● Vanderbilt gets short straw in negotiations for a casino Lansing Journal 10.06.02 ● Indians aim to drive family from tribe in vicious dispute san diego union tribune 04.09.00 ●Malik owns 2000 Michigan Quarter Horse of the Year Michigan.gov 01.01.00 ● Detroit Team to run Michigan’s newest Indian casino detnews.com 05.23.99 ● Tiger ties tangle Marian Ilitch detnews.com 04.29.99 ● Three investors must sell their Detroit casino interests gamblingmagazine.com 04.25.99 ● Partners’ cash revived election; They say money was crucial to Prop-E detnews.com 04.25.99 ● Investors have troubled histories las vegas review journal 04.27.99 ● Investor served probation for domestic assault on 12 year old boy detnews.com 04.25.99 ● Can a pair win a jackpot?: local men hope to... crainsdetroit.com 03.17.97

The Verifiable Truth